What Does TIDE Have to Say?

We should discuss what a proper TIDE perspective would be on matters such the issues raised by this WSJ article. https://www.wsj.com/world/middle-east/israel-palestinians-prison-treatment-eec50302?st=ewmxWF&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink

Here is another issue where it would be good to clarify what TIDE has to say. While I am at odds with Rabbi Slifkin on many matters, here he is essentially just quoting, and the quotes are disturbing. The people whom he is quoting could argue that they are just good Austritters, and the question is boundary line between legitimate Austritt and illegitimate demonization. I think Rabbi Schwab did specifically draw an Austritt line between Agudism and Religious Zionism. Thus Speaketh Daas Torah - by Natan Slifkin

Austritt includes no money taken or accepted.

By definition, I would venture, the dialogue and tone would be a different בריה.

More fundamentally, in no way shape or form can the currect haredi relationship with the state be defined as Austritt.

1 Like

This is by far the worst I have ever seen on this topic. In the 9 days. And this time it is not some quote in some newspaper from some random Rosh Hayeshiva.

It comes directly from people called “Gedoilei Yisroel”. It is all on tape.

H’ Yerachem.

Even if TIDE leads you to the conclusion not join the army (which I would disagree with - but it still could be) there is just no way a ben Toire with a sensitivity for TIDE would have said these things.

..and for the record, IBG and Smot. (who I would not vote for based on what I am aware of today) have also potential for some TIDE improvements. But it is different. They dont claim so speak for all RZ and they dont always claim what they do is in the name of the Tora. And their voters generally dont boycott the state.

And there are many more differences.

As an under-statement of the century, both camps would definitely gain from a TIDE infusion.

1 Like

I understood Rav Lando differently and I think it raises important points relating to TIDE. It seems to me like he was referring specifically to operations promoted by the likes of IBG that are nationalistic in nature.

This is not reality. He talks about a purely hypothetical case of IBG senden soldiers to die/kill for “nationalism”?

With all the things that are going on, this is what he wants to talk about? This is a shaile that comes up on a daily basis, that 2 other Mirrer RH had to be there? When is the last time IBG sent his police force to murder arabs for the sole reason of his “nationalism”? There is much more to say, but for the 9 days, this should do. Again, no fan of IBG, but to claim that is what worries the “Gadol Hador” is highly questionable.

And if he touches the issue of soldiers, than the “Gadol Hador” can not spare one single positive word of appriciation for the part of society that does serve? Can you send me ANY statement EVER of him mentioning RZ in a positive way?

This is defending the indefensible.

1 Like

Quotes from Rav Elias’s Dvar Tora on Vaetchanan:

“In other words, it is not enough to pursue worthy goals; they must
be pursued in a way that inspires the confidence and respect of
those around us. A dismissive or flippant attitude toward how others
,ישר perceive one’s conduct falls short of the Torah’s demand of
which calls upon us to live in a manner that is beyond reproach in
and the eyes of Hashem and of humanity.
”
(…)
”The words of the Neziv are both historical and prescient. Each year, over נצי״
we are presented with powerful multimedia presentations ,תשעה באב
and warning of the devastating שמירת הלשון extolling the virtues of
We hear moving stories of Jews who were .שנאת חינם consequences of
and ultimately found their way תורה ומצוות once far removed from
back to Yiddishkeit. Yet, little, if anything, is said about those who
who hold different שומרי תורה ומצוות publicly brand entire segments of
and לשון הרע and the like. While we rightly condemn ערב רב as the דעות
this manifestation of the same destructive tendency when ,שנאת חינם
it is wrapped in religious zeal too often passes without rebuke .
דבר ה׳ demands an internalization of ועשית הישר והטוב , In summary
that informs every facet of our conduct, even in areas that do not
It teaches that all expressions of .איסור or מצוה involve an explicit
and that the ends ,דבר ה׳ as defined by טוב must be grounded in ישרות
requires ישרות , do not necessarily justify the means. Furthermore
that we sometimes forgo what we are rightfully entitled to for the
sake of the greater good. It also demands that, even when acting in
we consider how our actions are ,טוב accordance with the dictates of
in משנה and conduct ourselves accordingly. As the בעיני אדם perceived
הוא היה אומר, כל שרוח הבריות נוחה הימנו, רוח המקום נוחה הימנו , teaches אבות
one who conducts himself in a manner that earns the esteem of others
likewise earns the favor of Hashem.
”

2 Likes

Another thing TIDE should have something to say about…

Check this out from the BBC: Israeli West Bank settler tells BBC attacks on Palestinians are justified as revenge

Neither דינא דמלכותא דינא, nor סכנה, nor חלול ה’ should normally require a TIDE angle to be normative and imperative. Woe to the general state of affairs, if they do require such….