Torah IM Derech Eretz

The “Science of Judaism” (Wissenschaft des Judentums) movement, which began in early 19th-century Germany, sought to study Judaism academically, using historical and critical methods. At the time of Rav Samson Raphael Hirsch, this movement was viewed with significant suspicion and concern by many traditional rabbinic leaders.

What was the impact and threat of ,”Science of Judaism?”

What I heard—I think Berl Wein z”l writes about this—there was a question for after his times.

He was greatly respected for what he did for the yidden in Germany. The question is: was his vision for the doros later.

Rabbi Brueur understood from his shver that he desired this change in orthodoxy willingly and to last despite Haskalah—while many of our gedolim looked at rabbi rsr”h as horoas sho

While Rav J. Breuer was certainly a staunch supporter–I assume you mean the mesorah he received from his father Rav Shlomo Breuer, and grandfather, RSRH–the same idea is absolutely expressed by RSRH himself, in no equivocal terms.

Question is only did the Eastern gedolim have access to these writings, and if not, perhaps really thought they were expressing RSRH’s position. Otherwise, and in any case, the horaas shaah view is an expression of their views (i.e. RSRH saved Germany but this shitah is not for us/not ideal), not those of RSRH himself.

1 Like